It will have
been the Spirit
André Luiz the
Dr. Carlos
Chagas?
"Two methods can
be used to fix
ideas about the
unclear issues:
first, is to
submit all
communications
to the severe
test of
reason,
common sense and
logic, the
second criterion
of truth is in
concordance
education."
(Allan Kardec in
What is the
Spiritism -
c. 2, n. 99.)
In the book "The
Next Dimension"
of the Ignatius
Ferreira,
psychographics
Carlos A.
Baccelli, 1st
edition, we
read:
1ª - c.33,
p.210, "... but
responding to
him, tell him
that I must
forget, and no
longer remember
that one day I
was Carlos
Chagas, I forget
that I am André
Luiz..." (sic);
and in the c.35,
p.221, we see:
"... including
the lower spirit
zones, where I
spent about
eight
years..."'; and
2ª - c.35,
p.222, "...
including the
lower spirit
zones, where
|
|
I spent
about
eight
years...".
|
|
Let's look at
such passages in
the light of
logic, common
sense and
reason,
following the
teachings of
Kardec in
question. To do
so we must
contextualize
them in the face
of biographical
details of his
two sons and
Evandro Chagas
Filho,
information
provided by the
Emmanuel's
presentation of
the Spirit Andre
Luiz, entitled
"New Friend",
dated 3/10/1943
and constant in
the book Astral
City; data and
situations told
by the Spirit
Andre Luiz in
books Astral
City and The
Messengers, and
information
given by the
Spirit brother
Jacob in the
book I returned.
All books were
psychographed by
Francisco
Cândido Xavier.
First, treat the
second passage
above,
considering it
valid as
consistent with
the passage of
c. 7 of Our
Home, where
Lysias says:
"You aren't
aware yet, are
you, that your
stay in the
lower spheres
lasted over
eight years? ".
The data show
the mathematical
impossibility of
the Spirit
Carlos Chagas
had written the
book Astral City
In validating
this passage, it
should check the
logical-mathematical
ability to be
Dr. Carlos
Chagas, the
spiritual author
of the book Our
Home, as his
biographical
books and
chronographs
Astral City,
The
Messengers
and I
Returned as
follows:
A – Death of
Carlos Chagas:
8/11/1934;
B - Date of
presentation
"New Friend"
from Emmanuel:
3/10/1943, book
Astral City;
C - Preface from
Emmanuel in
The Messengers:
in 25/2/1944;
and,
D - Time to
create affinity
between André
Luiz and Chico
Xavier: 700
consecutive
days, I
Returned the
book, c. 1,
confirmed by
letter of Chico
Xavier,
12/10/1946, to
Wantuil de
Freitas,
according to
book
"Testimonies of
Chico Xavier",
1st Ed FEB, p.
97-99.
E - Indefinite
period between
the redemption
of Carlos Chagas,
Spirit, on the
Threshold and
the beginning of
the period of
seven hundred
days to create
affinity with
Chico Xavier,
because if the
Threshold, had
need of
treatment,
rehabilitation
and education in
order to become
fit for mister
writer
spiritual.
If we correlate
the above data
and performing
an addition,
like so:
8/11/1934 + 8
years + 1 years
and 11 months
(700 days) +
time = 8/10/1944
+ indefinite
time period, we
conclude,
therefore, the
impossibility
mathematics of
the Spirit
Carlos Chagas
had written the
book Our Home,
the conclusion
was given, no
more than
3/10/1943, to be
the date on
which Emmanuel
has given us the
Spirit of André
Luiz.
Added to that,
the result of
the above sum,
the book The
Messengers can’t
also have been
written by Dr.
Carlos Chagas,
in view of the
date of the
preface to
Emmanuel, for
this work be
25/2/1944.
If we assume a
similar time
period for
treatment,
rehabilitation
and education of
Dr. Carlos
Chagas as
described by
Andre Luiz in
Our Home, the
book Light of
Missionaries,
foreword by
Emmanuel de
13/5/1945, can’t
be the mining of
Dr. Carlos
Chagas, Spirit,
in addition, the
book Workers of
Eternal Life,
foreword by
Emmanuel de
25.3.1946, is
under suspicion
as to their
spiritual
writer.
There is, also,
the moral
question to
consider.
Carlos Chagas
was orphan of
father to the
four years and
he would not
have conditions
of participating
in businesses as
André narrated
Let us see the
statements of
Emmanuel when
presenting in
André Luiz:
1) "
There no social
records for a
physician named
André Luiz."
2) "
Often real
understanding
and true love
come to us
hidden under the
cloak of
anonymity."
3) "
Nevertheless, we
are glad to have
drawn to our
spiritual
circles one who
might transmit
an account of
his own
experiences. He
gives as much
detail as
possible to
clarify the laws
that preside
over the efforts
of diligent
Spirits of good
will in spheres
which are
invisible to
human eyes,
although
intimately
connected the
planet."
(accentuated)
4) "
Keep this lesson
in the book of
your soul. They
remind us that
it is not enough
for man to cling
to his human
existence. It is
necessary to
know how to use
that existence
worthy…"
(accentuated).
Analyzing these
claims Emmanuel,
we see that
while the
anonymity given
by the Spirit
communicator, to
be called Andre
Luiz, he reports
that he
experiences
after his
disembodied,
changing only
what is
necessary to
preserve their
anonymity for
the sake of his
family still in
the flesh. We do
not have the
consistency of
the Holy
Emmanuel, as the
Spirit mentor
Chico Xavier,
revealed in his
books and
messages, in the
course of
psychic
experience of
our beloved
Chico, why doubt
when he urges us
to keep the book
of soul André
Luiz experience,
whoever he is.
Making
abstraction of
the time factor
after the
disembodied Dr.
Carlos Chagas,
there are
passages in the
book Our Home,
in the face of
assertions of
Emmanuel, that
the Spirit Andre
Luiz talked
about their own
experiences, are
characterized by
complete
inability, as
the passage
narrated Chapter
35 - Meeting
Singular, where
Andrew is the
Holy Luiz
Silveira, former
creditor of her
father, getting
embarrassed as
he says: "I
wanted to
apologize and
yet could not
find phrases
just because, on
occasion, my
father also
encouraged to
consummate the
unjust attack
...". However,
Carlos Chagas
was fatherless
at four years
old and would
not be able to
participate in
any event,
business adult
how André Luiz
narrated.
Carlos Chagas
had two
children:
Evandro Chagas
and Carlos
Chagas Filho;
André Luiz had
two daughters
and a son
There is also
the question of
the family to
consider. Carlos
Chagas had two
children:
Evandro Chagas
who died in 1940
in Rio de
Janeiro, of a
plane crash, and
Carlos Chagas
Filho, who died
in 2000,
Catholic,
balanced life,
managing to be
president of the
Pontifical
Academy of
Sciences of the
Vatican. Both
were doctors.
In the sites
below we can
obtain data on
the terrestrial
family of the
Dr. Carlos
Chagas: a) http://www.etall.hpg.ig.com.br/chagas.htm;
b) http://www.medio.com.br/index.php
(research for
Carlos Chagas);
c) http://www.coc.fiocruz.br/areas/dad/guia_acervo/index.htm;
d) http://www.coc.fiocruz.br/manguinhos/carlos.htm.
We see from
these data that
at the time of
extraction of
the book Our
Home, the
earthly family
of Dr. Carlos
Chagas it was
only his wife
and one child,
whereas the
other had
disembodied
while Andre Luiz
tells us that he
had two
daughters and a
son incarnate
when he returned
in spirit, the
old home.
There are other
tests to be
done, but we
completed
transcribing the
advice of St.
Louis Spirit,
set out in
paragraph 266 of
The Book of
Mediums:
"Whatever the
legitimate
expectation that
you will inspire
the spirits who
preside over
your
deliberations, a
recommendation
is that will
never be
repeated too
often and that
you must always
bear in mind in
your memory when
they deliver you
to your studies:
is to weigh and
meditate, is to
submit to the
crucible of
reason more
severe all the
communications
they receive, is
to not let
asking
explanations
necessary to
form an opinion
safe, since a
point appears
suspicious,
doubtful or
obscure.
"
Let us study
Kardec!
Nota:
The article
above was
published
initially in the
site:
http://www.institutoandreluiz.org/ca_pedro_bezerra_neto.html
Our sister Lori
Marli dos
Santos, head of
the institution
that maintains
the site,
expressly
authorized the
publication of
the article in
our magazine,
with a view to
its relevance
and timeliness.
|