The Good and
Evil
(Part 1)
Get rid of the
evil we will
instruct us and
practicing
Christian
charity. The
study will allow
us to discern
what is in
accordance with
the laws of God
and what is not
1.
INTRODUCTION
Since the most
ancient times,
man has been
questioned about
the existence of
evil. In this
small study will
seek to explain
the different
explanations
given to the
question of evil
throughout
history, showing
that the
difficulty of
being human to
understand it
was due to the
lack of a prior
understanding of
how we had been
and why of life,
understanding
this which the
Doctrine came to
offer.
2.
THE MYTH
OF ADAM AND EVE
According to the
biblical book of
Genesis, the
couple lived in
the primeval
Garden of Eden,
where he was
happy and
carefree, having
been seen in all
their needs by
divine
providence.
However, the
myth that God
had forbidden
Adam and Eve to
eat from the
tree of
knowledge of
good and evil,
telling them
that if they
did, they would
die (Gen 2:17).
It turns out
that when Adam
and Eve tasted
the fruit of the
tree of
knowledge of
good and evil,
they were not
killed by God in
the strict sense
of the verb to
kill. They were,
rather, expelled
from Eden and
forced to "eat
the bread by the
sweat of their
brow."
The
interpretation
of the myth is
clear in the
light of
Spiritism, as
expounded in our
article Adam and
Eve, published
by International
Magazine of
Spiritism, in
October 2004.
The souls that
animated the
humanoids living
the happy lives
of other beings
of the animal
kingdom, living
with them in the
harmony of
nature, each
species evolved
in its own way,
interacting with
others and
developing their
emotional and
rational
intelligence.
When the moral
conscience of
these souls
reached
maturity, they
become spirits,
entering the
human’s realm.
What is the
maturity of
conscience but
the knowledge of
good and evil,
the fruit of the
forbidden tree,
according to the
myth of the
primeval
couple?
Having entered
the human’s
realm, the
souls, turned
into spirits,
began to submit
to the Law of
Causality,
becoming
responsible for
their actions.
The loss of
innocence is
represented in
the myth of Adam
and Eve by
conditioning the
evolution of the
need of work,
food obtained
"by the sweat of
the brow." The
evolution in the
animal kingdom
does not depend
on merit, since
the species do
not have a
mature
conscience.
Humans, however,
is responsible
for their
actions, only to
evolve, so their
improvement
efforts in the
light of
knowledge of
good and evil
have purchased.
3.
MANICHAEISM
The name
"Manichaeism"
derives from the
fact that this
religion was
created by a
philosopher
named Mani, who
lived in Persia
(now Iran) in
the second
century and who
said he received
it from an angel
who had visited.
The Manichaeism
was one of the
major religions
of the region of
ancient Persia
(now Iran) and
has a dualistic
view of the
world, whose
domain, for it
was in eternal
conflict between
two opposing
forces, good and
evil. Although
extinct in its
original form
since the
thirteenth
century,
Manichaeism
religion still
survives as a
small scale
under the name
of
neo-Manichaeism.
However, in
spite of
Manichaeism, as
a religion, find
themselves today
restricted to
small
communities
around the
world, the
dualistic view
of reality that
he preaches is
far from having
disappeared,
having been
found present in
various moments
of history from
ancient remote
until our
century and in
all cultures.
Manichean are
all views that
reduce any
aspect of life
to pairs of
opposing ideas
and views as
mutually
exclusive, such
as:
- In politics,
"right" is
placed in
opposition to
"Left";
- In religion,
"true" is set up
against
"infidel",
"pure" to
"impure",
"sinner" to
"holy", "good"
to "evil" and
"saved" to
"damned."
- Social
relations:
"white" is
placed in
opposition to
"black",
"superior" to
"low", "rabble"
to "elite", and
so on.
Sectarian
religions are
Manichean when
they teach that
the individual
or the following
or is condemned
to hell. Both
the foreign
policy of the
U.S. government
in relation to
Al-Qaeda and the
Al-Qaeda in the
United States
were political
Manichean, like
so many before
had been
throughout
history, the
cause or the
pretext of war,
persecution and
all sort of
violence among
men.
The existence of
opposites is
what
characterizes
the Manichaeism,
a dualistic view
of the world,
but the belief
that such
opposites are in
perpetual
struggle and
that are
irreconcilable
and mutually
exclusive
forever, leaving
no room for
differences,
which are by
everywhere and
are visible to
all those who
have eyes to
see.
In the words of
psychoanalyst
and teacher
Raymundo de
Lima:
"Manichaeism
does not hold
for long,
because of its
dogmatism, that
is, their
inability to put
to the test of
reality or
logic, its
truths
simplified. As
your thinking is
reduced to a
pair of
antagonistic
truths,
accepting the
reasoning of the
other,
inconsistent
means being
dragged into the
domain of evil
and be engulfed
by it. The life
of Manichean
becomes a
readiness
surveillance
(paranoia),
appearing not to
be fooled with
the "seductive
speeches. St.
Augustine, who
was initially
Manichean,
having moved
away, wrote in
the Confessions
(Book 7) that
this doctrine
"had not found
peace and only
expressed
opinions of
others."
Although the
teacher has said
that
"Manichaeism
does not hold
for a long
time," what we
saw was that it
survives today
and is strongly
present in
social relations
in different
cultures. But
what is certain
and
indisputable,
however, is that
it will
disappear when
our beloved
Earth promoting
the world of
regeneration. In
these worlds
there is no room
for sectarian
dogmatism, is
predominant
everywhere in
the tolerance of
differences,
because everyone
will know that
such differences
are inherent in
the diversity of
evolutionary
levels between
humans.
4.
AUGUSTINE
OF HIPPO
Augustine of
Hippo, the St.
Augustine of our
fellow
Catholics,
puzzled at the
existence of
evil in a world
created by God,
supremely good,
conceived the
notion of evil
that prevails
today among
siblings of
Catholic and
evangelical
belief. He said
that everything
that exists is
necessarily
good, because
the idea would
be consistent
and the idea of
being there. The
evil would thus
be deprived of
real existence,
being reduced to
homelessness,
corruption of
good.
Evil, for
Augustine, is a
transgression of
divine law,
since the soul
was created by
God to govern
the body, and
man, misusing
the free will,
makes the soul
to the body.
Focusing on the
matter, the soul
degenerates, and
deluded by the
sensations, it
is considered
itself as body.
So far, we can
say that the
doctrine of
Augustine has
several points
of contact with
Spiritualism.
For us, spirit,
everything God
created, that is
their sovereign
and immutable
laws, is good.
As we shall see,
Spiritualism
also teaches us
that evil is a
transgression of
God's laws. The
continuation of
the doctrine of
Augustine,
however, is
totally opposed
to the
understanding
spirit, as we
shall see.
For the bishop
of Hippo, in
this state of
decay in which
the soul is, she
cannot save
themselves by
their own
forces. The fall
of man is the
responsibility
of man, as a
result of their
free will.
However, the
free will that
caused the fall
of man is not
enough to make
it back to
divine origins.
This power is
the privilege of
God. This is the
Augustinian
doctrine of
predestination
and grace.
Let us,
therefore, the
understanding
Spiritist.
5.
UNDERSTANDING
SPIRITIST
5.1. In The
Spirits' Book
629. What
definition can
be given of the
moral law?
"The moral law
is the rule for
acting aright,
that is to say,
for
distinguishing
practically
between good and
evil. It is
founded on the
observance of
the law of God.
Man acts rightly
when he takes
the good of all
as his aim and
rule of action;
for he then
obeys the law of
God."
630. How can we
distinguish
between good and
evil?
“Good is
whatever is in
conformity with
the law of God;
and evil is
whatever
deviates from it.
Thus, to do
right, is to
conform to the
law of God; to
do wrong, is to
infringe that
law."
631. Has man of
himself the
means of
distinguishing
what is good
from what is
evil?
“Yes, when he
believes in God,
and desires to
do what is
right. God
has given him
intelligence in
order that he
may distinguish
between them.”
632. As man is
subject to error
may he not be
mistaken in his
appreciation of
good and evil,
and believe
himself to be
doing right,
when, in
reality, he is
doing wrong?
“Jesus has said:
'Whatsoever
ye would that
men should do
unto you, do ye
even so to them.'
The whole moral
law is contained
in that
injunction. Make
it your rule of
action, and you
will never go
wrong.”
633. The rule of
good and evil,
what may be
called the rule
of reciprocity
or solidarity,
cannot be
applied to a
man's to
personal conduct
towards himself.
Does He find, in
natural
law, the rule of
that conduct,
and a safe
guide?
“When you eat
too much, it
hurts you. God
gives you, in
the discomfort
thus produced,
the measure of
what is
necessary for
you. When you
exceed that
measure, you are
punished. It is
the same with
everything else.
Natural law
traces out for
each man the
limit of his
needs. When he
oversteps that
limit he is
punished by the
suffering thus
caused. If
men gave heed,
in all things,
to the voice
which says to
them 'enough!'
they would avoid
the greater part
of the ills of
which they
accuse nature.”
634. Why does
evil exist in
the nature of
things? I speak
of moral evil.
Could not God
have created the
human race in
more favorable
conditions?
“We have already
told you that
spirits are
created simple
and ignorant
(115). God
leaves man free
to choose his
road; so much
the worse for
him if he takes
the wrong one;
his pilgrimage
will be all the
longer. If there
were no
mountains, man
could not
comprehend the
possibility of
ascending and
descending; if
there were no
rocks, he could
not understand
that there are
such things as
hard bodies. It
is necessary for
the spirit to
acquire
experience; and,
to that end, he
must know both
good and evil.
It is for this
purpose that
souls are united
to bodies.”
(This article
will be
concluded in the
next edition of
this magazine.)
References:
1. COSTA, Renato.
Adam and Eve In
International
Journal of
Spiritualism,
October 2004.
2. Kardec,
Allan. Genesis,
the Miracles and
Predictions
According to
Spiritism. 36.
ed. Rio de
Janeiro: FEB,
1995.
3. Id The
Spirits’ Book.
76. ed.
Rio de Janeiro:
FEB, 1995.
4. LIMA,
Raymundo.
Manichaeism: The
Good, Evil and
its Effects
Yesterday and
Today. Space
Magazine
Academic Year I,
07, December
2001.
5. SAMPAIO,
Rudini. St.
Augustine, Key
Elements of the
Doctrine.
Retrieved on
29/05/2006 from
http://www.ime.usp.br/~rudini/filos.agostinho.htm.
|